Still gently planning the homeschool year. In fact, I nodded to Luke Holtzmann on Twitter about it: I can see why buying a year's worth of scheduled readings, with open-ended discussion questions included, all for great, REAL books that are a joy to read... is a heck of a lot easier than doing it all yourself, from scratch.
I didn't go with Sonlight again for several reasons.
1. *Sonlight is Christian but not Catholic*. Sonlight's religious materials are Evangelical Protestant in tone and mission, which can be fine - or intolerable. This year, I am focusing on teaching Roman Catholicism to our kids, and I need the materials to support that. In our last Core I used Sonlight's books and stressed the commonalities that all Trinitarian Christians share. This year, I need more than that. I could have gotten a Core but not the Bible, but the EP overtones are present in many of the other subjects too, notably History, Literature and Science.
2. *Sonlight doesn't have a Middle Ages Core*. The Middle Ages are covered in Sonlight's World History Cores, but we wanted more detail. Winter Promise makes a full-year Middle Ages program but they also have the same trouble as reason 1 above.
3. *Sonlight is 36 weeks, and we wanted 45*. We'll be doing four days a week for 45 weeks. Sonlight has a great four-day option that's included with every Core but it's still only 36 weeks.
4. *Sonlight is slightly more expensive*. Honestly, this isn't much of a reason. I doubt I've saved much money. I've been able to buy a few things used, and I don't have the expense of the Instructor's Guide. Sonlight isn't raking in the dough. Their Cores are expensive but you get real value for your money.
That's about it. We will likely return to Sonlight in the future. Their High School Cores are very intriguing, and having everything just In A Box and DONE is worth a lot, let me tell you.
I'll publish our schedule and booklist when I finish. I'm doing the first 15 weeks, so if we just hate it I won't have wasted as much time.